LAB · UQ MASTER’S PROJECT · LEAN STARTUP

Whorl’d

The startup idea I killed, and why.

The startup idea I killed, and why.

The startup idea I killed, and why.

I tested whether travelers would rent used electronics instead of buying them. People liked the idea, not the devices. And the numbers didn’t work.

ROLE

Solo project: research, customer discovery, business model

TIMELINE

Jan 2024 – Apr 2024

METHODS

Customer interviews · Hypothesis testing · Value proposition canvas · Market mapping · MVP concept

OUTCOME

Stopped before build

ROLE

Solo project: research, customer discovery, business model

TIMELINE

Jan 2024 – Apr 2024

METHODS

Customer interviews · Hypothesis testing · Value proposition canvas · Market mapping · MVP concept

OUTCOME

Stopped before build

THE IDEA

Whorl’d would rent used electronics to people who only need them for a while. Devices would come from local second-hand shops, be delivered to wherever the customer was staying, and be collected at the end. Whorl’d would own, check and guarantee every device. The first customers would be travelers, especially digital nomads, with hotels as a second, business-to-business channel.

WHY IT SEEMED WORTH TESTING

E-waste is growing faster than recycling. In 2019 the world produced an estimated 53.6 million metric tons, and only 17.4% was formally collected and recycled. The average Australian produces about 20 kg a year, against a global average of 7 kg. Renting instead of buying looked like a way to keep devices in use longer.

WHAT I TESTED

I wrote down what had to be true, then tried to prove each belief wrong. I mapped the market and its competitors, then interviewed travelers, second-hand buyers and sellers, a repair shop, and a hotel manager at a global chain.

People will join a circular-economy model if the path is easy

CHALLENGED

People will choose the more affordable option

CHALLENGED

People who buy or sell used electronics do it out of need

CHALLENGED

People will use a pre-owned device without worrying it’ll fail

CHALLENGED

People will act sustainably as long as it doesn’t cost them comfort

CONFIRMED

What people will spend depends on how long they’ll use it and what they get from it

CONFIRMED

WHAT I LEARNED

Trust, not price, was the first barrier. Whorl’d would guarantee every device, so scams weren’t the worry. Second-hand itself was: most people preferred to own new, and a used device felt like inheriting someone else’s problems, unless it came free with a hotel room. Sustainability didn’t make up for it, either. Everyone said they cared about it, but nobody went looking for sustainable options, and some didn’t trust the claims at all.


The opportunity was real. Digital nomads working from anywhere looked like the biggest growth market. The hospitality side confirmed the trend: hotels were already keeping devices for guests to rent. But big chains would rather buy and own theirs, so smaller hotels were the better partner.

Stop.

Three problems stacked up. Repairs ate the profit, travelers didn’t trust second-hand devices, and manufacturers were launching travel-ready ones.

WHY I STOPPED

The idea solved a real annoyance, but not one worth what it would cost to run. Rented devices get damaged and lost, and each repair ate the margin: parts were expensive and hard to find, and newer devices are designed to be harder to fix. Few travelers wanted a second-hand device anyway. Meanwhile, manufacturers were already making lighter, travel-ready devices. Any one of these was fixable. All three together weren’t.

WHAT I’D DO DIFFERENTLY


I’d set my kill criteria before the first interview. I found the fatal cost late, after the business model was drawn. Today I’d write the line first: the numbers that would make me stop.

Kill criteria, in hindsight

Kill criteria, in hindsight

Written after the project, not before it. This is what I’d set now.

Repair and replacement cost per rental stays under 8% of rental revenue

Repair costs outweighed projected profit

FAIL

Spare parts are available at predictable cost

Parts were costly and hard to find

FAIL

Travelers would rent rather than bring their own devices

Manufacturers were launching lighter, travel-ready devices

FAIL

Customers would rent a used device if its quality was guaranteed

Most preferred owning new; used felt like inheriting someone else’s problems

FAIL

E-waste figures: World Health Organization (2023); Australian Government Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (2023).

Next: Diagnosing innovation

Next: Diagnosing innovation

Read the next project →

Have an idea
worth testing?

Get in touch

LinkedIn

Medellín, Colombia · UTC−5 · English & Spanish · hello@marcelaareizajaramillo.com

© 2026 Marcela Areiza Jaramillo